2015年10月8日星期四

Theme6: Qualitative and case study research

The paper I chose:
Malin, J. B. (2011) A very popular blog: The internet and the possibilities of publicity. New Media & Society. 13(2), 187-202

1. Which qualitative method or methods are used in the paper? Which are the benefits and limitations of using these methods?

This paper use a typical qualitative method to discuss the implication of two modes of publicity for traditional broadcast and online communications. Referring to relative literatures and previous research, the authors trace a lot of examples and compare them to analysis explain the implication of broadcast, cable television and internet.

Benefit: Qualitative methods used in the paper make a good combination between statistics from research institutions or media companies and relative theoretical literatures. As the discussion is based on a large amount of examples from previous research, they analysis by comparing the examples to get most reliable conclusion. In addition, without the processing of collecting data, the method is less complex because it concentrates on a representative sample(US).
Limitation:The main content is using previous study to analysis and give explanation of the implication, while the general conclusion is not objective enough and probably influenced by researcher and method from reference. A research without data supported lack of accuracy.

2. What did you learn about qualitative methods from reading the paper?

Compared with quantitative method, qualitative method describes and explain the object based on general theories and a great amount of history and examples. Comparison and logical analyzing are the main ways to do qualitative research and the opinions from author significantly influenced the conclusion. It aims to explain social phenomenon.

3. Which are the main methodological problems of the study? How could the use of the qualitative method or methods have been improved?

Although the topics of the paper is implication of publicity of traditional medium(broadcast and television) and internet, the reflection is in terms of humans. While the research do not apply an quantitative method that means no data collection and statistics verify the conclusion. Taking a survey of a large number of participants to focus on their opinions about two modes of publicity, then the study can result from the collected data to verify the reliability of previous conclusion.


Selected paper:
Nicole B. Ellison et al (2007) The Benefits of Facebook “Friends:” Social Capital and College Students’. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication. Volume 12, Issue 4, July 2007, Pages: 1143–1168

1. Briefly explain to a first year university student what a case study is.

Case study is one solution to build theory. The case study is a research strategy which focuses on understanding the dynamics present within single settings. case studies can be used to accomplish various aims: to provide description, test theory and generate theory. Case study is a typical combination of qualitative research and quantitative research such as interviews, questionnaires and observations.

2. Use the "Process of Building Theory from Case Study Research" (Eisenhardt, summarized in Table 1) to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of your selected paper.

According to the structure of building theory from case study research, selected paper definitely match  the whole system. In terms of cross-case search for patterns, the paper used all the tactics recommended to sort and analysis the data, multiples lenses about result for social capital items are showed. The conclusion based on empirical data analysis is a excellent ends regarded as reaching closure.

On the other hand, the sample participants of the investigation are completely undergraduate students and even from the same university, it seems do not correspond to multiple investigators. In addition, less comparison with other literature , no matter similarity or conflict appears in the discussion.

2015年10月4日星期日

Comments for Theme 3





Theme4: Quantitative Research (after)

The main topics of this week are more directly relative to scientific research. After the lecture, what I understand is that the quantitative research is based on a hypothesis. The whole processing can be described as beginning with a hypothesis, the research try to recruit a large number of participants to get involved in the test by questionnaire or observation to collect data. Then according to statistics, they conduct the experiment and analysis to verify whether the hypothesis is authentic. The most impressive part I learned in the lecture is how to create an appropriate questionnaire in quantitative research. Data collection plays an important role in quantitative research, as a result of that, we should try to concentrate on the feasibility, expression, interviewing procedure of questionnaire method. First formulating questions to interviewee is essential to make sure the most reliable data, then testing the questionnaire is also necessary which means validating it is helpful to check the problems which may happen during the procedure. In addition, piloting the test rightly cannot be ignored.

During the seminar, our group shared the methods of the research paper we read before this week respectively and mainly discussed the benefits and limitation of quantitative research and compared quantitative research and qualitative. After our discussion, I realized that quantitative research is  a proving or extension to the existed theory, while qualitative research is a process for organizing a theory which emphasize social phenomenas. As the two research method has their own benefits and also exist limitation, practical research usually combine them to solve problems. In terms of limitation of quantitative research, the experiment object generally are just a sample strategy,data, analyses and  even the result are based on the sample, but it is worth to mention that the reflection of  sample object cannot be regarded as the whole.


The lecture and seminar deal with a lot of confusion when I try to understand the quantitative research, and I got informative knowledge about scientific research. As an engineering student, quantitative research is extremely useful to solve problems for media technology.

2015年10月2日星期五

Theme5: Design research

Question for lecture on Wednesday:

1.How can media technologies be evaluated?
The evaluation is organized into experimental platform, usability evaluation which includes effectiveness, efficiency and satisfaction and trainability.

2.What role will prototypes play in research?
The prototypes is used for building an experimental system and carrying out user tests to collect experimental data for analyzing the feasibility of the research method. It appears when the desired system needs to have a lot of interaction with the end users.

3.Why could it be necessary to develop a proof of concept prototype?
 A proof of concept prototype is a realization of the research method to demonstrate its feasibility in principle, whose purpose is to verify the concept prototype has the potential of being adopted.
Developing a proof of concept prototype indicates concept prototype can be designed to obtain significant data for further research.

3.What are characteristics and limitations of prototypes?
The prototype is designed according to the original method and key ideas based on the currently known requirements. The type of prototype is global which means an entire system is included covering almost considered features.
While Incomplete application of prototype may cause application not to be used as the full system was designed.

4.How can design research be communicated/presented?
Successfully presenting the design research can focus on the evaluation to the prototype of participants and usability which means effectiveness, efficiency and satisfaction. The design research in “Turn Your Mobile Into the Ball: Rendering Live Football Game Using Vibration” written by Shafiq ur Réhman, Jiong Sun, Li Liu, and Haibo Li is really a excellent sample to learn a feasible communication of design research.
Question for lecture on Friday:

What is the 'empirical data' in these two papers?
The empirical data means knowledge gaining by means of direct and indirect observation or experience. In my opinion, it is contrasted with a prior knowledge.

1.Can practical design work in itself be considered a 'knowledge contribution'?

Yes, I agree with this idea. Practical design work which means testing the design and collect the reflection of user is a significant way to gain knowledge. According to the concept of “knowledge is perception”, it corresponds to the view in philosophy.
2.Are there any differences in design intentions within a research project, compared to design in general?

What I understand is that design within a research project is used to collect specific data for further study or evaluate the feasibility of the method in the research project. While common design concentrate on different aspect, less evaluation.
3.Is research in tech domains such as these ever replicable? How may we account for aspects such as time/historical setting, skills of the designers, available tools, etc? 
In my opinion, it is impossible that research in tech domains such as these papers can be replicable. As the three aspects mentioned, changes happened in any one factor of time/historical setting, skills of the designers and available tools could affect the research.
4.Are there any important differences with design driven research compared to other research practices?


Actually I am confused with this question. My understanding is that design driven research pay more attention to how to present the design to participant. For this type of research, the study is based on the design such as experimental data and the reflection of users. While other research practices usually appears in the pattern of that design is used to test and verify the method of researchs.

2015年9月27日星期日

Theme3: Research and Theory (after)

  The topic of this theme is more academic and abstract so that the texts to be somewhat harder than one in last week for me to understand. Before the lecture, I also take a long time to read texts and other relative papers but I still have a difficulty for understanding the main method. After one week, I think I got some informative and important points to the texts.

  In the lecture, the teacher give a impressive conclusion for theory which is theory is something we construct, it does not exist by itself. Theory is explaining what, why and how of an event or study. So how can a statement can become a real theory? According to the lecture, the answer can be that when a theory is tested and accepted by a majority of experts in a particular field, it can be regarded as true.


     During the seminar, the main question in our discussion is what theory is not. As the references indicates that data, list of variables or constructs, diagrams, hypotheses, references are not considered into theory. I really agree with the idea that theory is not practical. We also discussed a question that whether the theory can be categorized into good and bad? In my opinion, theory is concluded through practical identify or common experience, probably bad comments cannot pass the test and be accepted by the masses. Therefore my idea is that to some what theory is impossible to show as a bad one.
     
     In conclusion, the view that “nothing is so practical as a good theory” can support the method the texts described. Anyway, the lecture and seminar give me more clear understanding of theory. It is extremely meaningful for me in academic research and writing.

Comments for Theme 2

Here is the links to comments: